Private university colleges in Sultanate of Oman have implemented advanced technology in the educational system and many colleges have also been progressed by using the latest e-Learning Management Systems. Many colleges in Oman are affiliated with well-known reputed universities across the world to deliver advanced and quality education to the youth of Oman. However, it is imperative to evaluate the effectiveness of e-Learning in the private university colleges in Oman and with the affiliated college so that a comparative study could be conducted to analyze the quality of teaching and learning. This research done at Muscat College in Oman and University of Stirling, UK is an attempt to evaluate the effectiveness of e-learning technology in private university colleges in the Sultanate of Oman. This paper is determining the factors influencing the effectiveness of e-learning management systems. A questionnaire was addressed to 158 students and a representative sample of 120 students have been selected from year two, three and 4 four of honors’ bachelor degree programme of Muscat college and University of Stirling.